The penalty framework of D.Lgs. 138/2024
Art. 38 of D.Lgs. 138/2024 sets out a penalty system structured on three levels: administrative fines on the organisation, ancillary penalties (disqualification measures) and the personal liability of Management. The legislator chose to calibrate the size of the penalty on two variables: the nature of the entity (essential or important) and the seriousness of the conduct (omission vs. substantive breach, first occurrence vs. repeat offence, cooperation vs. obstruction).
Essential vs important entities: penalties compared
The difference between essential and important entities is not only substantive: it directly affects the size of the applicable penalties.
| Profile | Essential entity | Important entity |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory maximum | €10 million or 2% of total worldwide annual turnover (whichever is higher) | €7 million or 1.4% of total worldwide annual turnover (whichever is higher) |
| Supervisory regime | Ex ante: inspections, security audits, requests for evidence even when no incident has occurred | Ex post: checks only following a report, an incident or evidence of non-compliance |
| Disqualification measures | Possible (suspension of certifications, temporary ban on exercising managerial functions) | Possible in serious or repeat cases |
| Management liability | Personal and non-delegable (Art. 20 + 38) | Personal and non-delegable (Art. 20 + 38) |
Which conduct exposes an organisation to penalties
The conduct penalised under Art. 38 falls into four main groups:
- Failure to adopt the Art. 21 measures: missing or inadequate policies on risk analysis, incident response, business continuity, supply chain security, cryptography, multi-factor authentication and the other minimum technical measures.
- Failure to notify, or late notification of, significant incidents (Art. 25): missing the 24h / 72h / 1-month windows or substantially incomplete minimum content in the notifications.
- Governance and training shortcomings (Art. 20): no formal approval of the measures by the management body, no evidence of training for Management and staff, no periodic update of the training plan.
- Obstruction of ACN: refusing or delaying the provision of requested information, failing to update registration data, failing to comply with corrective measures imposed by ACN.
The personal liability of directors
The most debated aspect of Art. 38 is the personal liability of Management. This is not criminal liability (NIS2 is an administrative matter), but a liability that falls directly on the individual director, executive or board member who has breached their duties of approval and oversight. Possible consequences include individual fines, temporary suspension from office, a temporary ban on exercising managerial functions in NIS2 entities and referral to the company's governing bodies.
The liability goes with the role: for events that occurred during the term of office, it does not lapse on resignation. It is this feature that makes NIS2 training for Management not a nice-to-have but a direct matter of personal protection.
Mitigating and aggravating factors
Art. 38 expressly provides for mitigating and aggravating factors that can significantly shift the size of the penalty actually imposed. The main mitigating factors are:
- Active cooperation with ACN: transparency in the information provided, access to systems, collaboration during the investigation;
- Timely notification: strict compliance with the 24h / 72h / 1-month windows, even in the case of a serious incident;
- Adoption of corrective measures that are concrete and documented after the incident, before the penalty is imposed;
- Complete documentation of the training delivered (Art. 20) and of the Art. 21 measures in place at the time of the incident;
- No previous penalties or non-conformities identified by ACN.
The main aggravating factors:
- Repeat offences: repeated breaches of the same kind;
- Intent or gross negligence: intentional breaches or breaches resulting from serious negligence;
- Cross-border or systemic impact of the incident;
- Obstruction of ACN's supervisory activities;
- Failure to adopt the corrective measures imposed.
Why documentation is the best insurance policy
In practice, the difference between a maximum and a minimum penalty almost always comes down to the quality of the documentation available. During its investigation, ACN assesses not only whether the Art. 21 measures have been adopted, but also whether there is documentary evidence of them that can be traced over time: board-approved policies, training records, system logs, vulnerability assessment reports, incident response procedures, contracts with critical suppliers.
Documented compliance is what turns a possible maximum penalty into a minimum one — and in some cases it can avoid the penalty altogether, if the organisation shows that it did everything reasonable and the incident was nevertheless unavoidable.
How Easy Health supports in-scope organisations
At Easy Health we support organisations subject to NIS2 in three ways: gap analysis and remediation for the Art. 21 measures, documented training for Management, CISOs, IT technicians and staff (Art. 20) and operational support in dealings with ACN, particularly in the event of an incident. For an overview of D.Lgs. 138/2024, read our complete guide to NIS2; for the Art. 20 e-learning courses, visit the NIS2 Training page.