2023 marked 45 years since 1978, when Law 833 of 23 December 1978 (Legge 833 del 23 dicembre 1978), signed by Tina Anselmi, the first woman minister of the Italian Republic, established the National Health Service, a true pioneer on the international stage.
Its cornerstone principles of universality, equity and solidarity in access to care and rehabilitation have guided the development of our healthcare system, making it for a long time a world-class system in more than one ranking, even though in recent years it has slipped a few places.
Over these 45 years, however, much has changed, such as our life expectancy: in 1978 it was around 73 years, while in recent years it has reached around 83, a full 10 years more.
Furthermore, while the total population has changed little, from around 56 million in 1978 to around 58 million today, what has changed radically is its age structure: 45 years ago people over 60 made up around 17% of the population, whereas in 2022 they already accounted for over 31%.
The disparity becomes even more evident if we compare centenarians: fewer than 1,000 in 1978 and almost 20,000 in 2023.
These changes have increasingly tested our healthcare system and the professionals who are part of it, a strain made more acute by the recent pandemic, in which Italy was among the very first countries affected.
The growth of these challenges has, fortunately, been accompanied by the growth of numerous resources at our disposal, digital technologies foremost among them.
Their impact can be transformative, but to deliver their full potential in the service of people they also require profound legislative, organisational and cultural change.
Consider telemedicine in its many forms (teleconsultation, remote reporting, remote monitoring, etc.): a doctor can technically interact with a patient even at a great distance, overcoming the limit of geographical proximity, but if the regulatory framework does not allow them, for example, to issue prescriptions remotely, that limit remains.
From an organisational point of view, it becomes possible for specialists in a given discipline to see a greater number of patients who need those specific skills, maximising value for all parties involved.
Finally, for digital technology to deliver its full potential, a cultural change is needed, starting with an understanding of its potential for patients and their health and followed by a commitment to facilitating its adoption so as to bring its benefits closer: of all the changes required, this is perhaps the most complex, because it asks people to question, sometimes radically, long-established dynamics and habits.
The promise of Value-Based Healthcare
In 2006, Harvard Business School Press published a book containing theories destined to have a truly disruptive impact on healthcare: "Redefining Health Care: Creating Value-Based Competition on Results".
The book was written by Michael E. Porter, a world-renowned economist, and Elizabeth Olmsted Teisberg, an academic specialising in innovation: together they propose a model of healthcare delivery that aims to improve outcomes for patients in terms of health, defining "value" as health outcomes per unit of cost, across the entire cycle of care.
To understand this model fully, it is important to frame the concept of value, and it is Porter himself who helps us in "What is Value in Health Care", a 2010 publication.
In this text he introduces a three-tier classification:
- at the top is the health status achieved or retained (survival, or degree of health or recovery of original health).
- Immediately after come process indicators, such as the time taken to recover health and/or any adverse events that occurred, also taking their severity into account.
- Third and last is the sustainability of health, with as long-term a view of it as possible, also considering the consequences of treatment.
Keeping this hierarchy of value clearly in mind, the Value-Based Healthcare model suggests 5 major areas of intervention, resting on an essential foundation: the creation of an enabling technology infrastructure with very specific characteristics:
- the patient is at the centre and all of their data must be easily accessible, regardless of the departments or organisations they have been in contact with. This is the principle behind the Electronic Health Record (Fascicolo Sanitario Elettronico), an important goal that, not without difficulty, we are progressively seeking to achieve.
- It is based on standard definitions and conventions, shared and understood by all parties involved. Unfortunately, it still happens far too often today that the same test, repeated in different departments of the same hospital, returns different values because the equipment is calibrated differently: in the system proposed by Porter and Teisberg this must not happen.
- All of the patient's data must be in a single place, including doctors' and nurses' notes: a single source of knowledge, as reliable and clear as possible, reduces the chances of errors and delays.
- Anyone with a role in the patient's care pathway must be able to access their data as freely as possible. The advantages are many: for example, the chances of more accurate diagnoses increase and redundant procedures are avoided.
- The system must include templates and expert systems for each individual medical condition: this provision facilitates the sharing of, and adherence to, best practices that are as universal as possible.
- Information must be easily retrievable and interchangeable: to work at its best, the model requires the collection, processing and sharing of data, from the costs incurred for the individual patient to the value generated.
The efforts under way in Europe to create the European Health Data Space are moving in this direction, also strengthening the creation of shared value – another important concept for Porter – through regulatory provisions on the secondary use of data capable of overcoming the limits of current legislation.
The 5 major areas of intervention are also beginning to be reflected in developments in Italian and European healthcare:
it starts with the proposal to develop integrated care units (IPUs, Integrated Practice Units) specialised in specific clinical conditions.
A recent example in Italy is the Pancreas Units, with Lombardy leading the way in adopting a particularly efficient multidisciplinary model, building on an experience that has already proven its value: the Breast Units dedicated to the prevention and treatment of the various forms of breast cancer.
In Porter and Teisberg's model, staff, equipment and spaces specifically integrated and optimised to address the entire cycle of care for a given clinical condition, including the education of patients and their families – improve coordination, reduce waste and time lost for patients, and improve adherence to care protocols and patient outcomes.
The second area of intervention is the accurate recording of the costs of each step of the care pathway together with patient outcomes, in as standard a way as possible to allow comparisons and highlight good practices to be shared.
In Italy, an increasingly important role on this front is played by the National Outcomes Programme (Programma Nazionale Esiti), led by AGENAS: it is an evaluation tool supporting clinical and organisational audit programmes, which helps to assess levels of hospital care, community care and equity of healthcare provision.
The third key point in developing the VBHC model is the adoption of bundled prices for complete cycles of care (bundled payments):
Regardless of who bears the cost of the care experience, a payment model centred on the cycle of care rewards the organisations able to offer, overall, more value to patients, in the senses underpinning the VBHC model.
Under this model, individual services, however important, lose their centrality and become part of a whole that makes it possible to seek optimisations capable of maintaining or improving the value generated.
Finally, to conclude our overview of the major areas of intervention of VBHC, the last two on the list complement each other: the fourth proposes specialisation of facilities, with a narrower range of healthcare services combined with a greater ability to best serve specific needs.
In this way, the specialists in those facilities will be able to make the most of their professional expertise, entrusting integrated facilities with the management of other aspects and less complex cases.
The fifth point, working in synergy with the fourth, is the expansion of the geographical reach of specialised facilities and their network of integrated facilities, in a so-called hub-and-spoke model.
An example of this approach can be seen in the reduction in the number of birth centres: rationalising the facilities specialising in this activity ensures that the health professionals working in this field not only have access to appropriate tools, but also have significant experience and are therefore able to manage even the most problematic situations with better outcomes.
This change is cultural as well as structural: for many needs, Italians are used to turning to the nearest facility, with distance playing a greater role than it should in the choice of where to seek care.
In a VBHC model it is important that patients, too, learn to reward the best-performing facilities, turning to them – to their own advantage – even when they are less convenient geographically.
These new habits can also be encouraged by paying attention to the overall experience not only of patients but also of their families, making it easier for them to stay at or near the facility.
Value-Based Health Care worldwide and in Italy
Within a few years of its publication, the popularity of the VBHC model grew significantly, albeit unevenly: in retrospect, the presence or absence of structured, easily accessible data has been highlighted as an important factor in implementing this model successfully.
On precisely this front, since 2012 the growth of Value-Based Healthcare worldwide has also been supported by a non-profit organisation, ICHOM, the International Consortium for Health Outcomes Measurement: its aim is to realise the potential of VBHC by defining shared global standards for measuring the outcomes that matter most to patients and by encouraging the measurement of these outcomes in order to create more value for all parties involved.
Among the first countries to seize the opportunities of VBHC is Sweden: among the most significant examples, from 2015 the Karolinska university hospital, one of the most important in the country, was completely reorganised, abandoning the traditional division into departments and creating an organisational model based on 170 care pathways, 100 for the adult population and 70 for the paediatric population.
Implementing such a radical change on such a large scale was not painless: over time, alongside the overall merits of the model, numerous areas for improvement emerged, which prompted further developments.
In Italy, we can say that the turning point for VBHC has a date, 8 November 2017: it was on this day that, during the World Business Forum in Milan, Michael Porter himself presented the event "The Value Agenda for Italy – Le soluzioni operative della Value Based Health Care in Italia per rilancio e crescita del Servizio Sanitario Nazionale" (operational Value Based Health Care solutions in Italy for the revival and growth of the National Health Service), promoted by Medtronic Italia.
Subsequently, in Italy too the popularity of this model grew over time, through a succession of experiences and reviews, such as the Harvard Business Review webinar of 24 November 2021, sponsored by Roche Diagnostic, entitled "Implementare il Value Based Healthcare in Italia: il caso Humanitas" (Implementing Value Based Healthcare in Italy: the Humanitas case), which presented and discussed a real case of value-based redesign of a clinical pathway (breast cancer) by Istituto Clinico Humanitas.
Again, at the end of 2021 Roche supported the development of a White Paper by Harvard Business Review Italia Analytic Services entitled "Le sei priorità per implementare il Value Based Healthcare in Italia" (The six priorities for implementing Value Based Healthcare in Italy): this document sets out around 20 cases that, at least in part, have features in line with the model.
This number shows that the adoption of Value-Based Healthcare in Italy is still in its early stages, and therefore that the potential it can deliver is still very high.
In November 2023, Harvard Business Review also presented an interesting case study of an initiative conducted by Istituti Clinici Scientifici Maugeri with the support of Takeda and Your Business Partner, in which the VBHC model meets the HCD methodology (Human-Centred Design), a now well-established methodology that makes it possible to design and build, through an iterative process, interactive systems that are as well suited as possible to improving people's experience in a specific context.
Value-Based Healthcare and Digital Patient Engagement
This last experience, in which Value-Based Healthcare found a natural match with the HCD methodology, highlights the importance of patient involvement in maximising the impact of VBHC-based initiatives.
The ability of well-designed Digital Patient Engagement experiences to support a better user experience and, as the ultimate goal, better health outcomes makes this resource one of the fundamental elements of any project that follows Porter and Teisberg's model.
Value for patients, in its many forms, is measured – thanks in part to the standards developed by ICHOM – not only through the clinical evidence of laboratory tests or patient observation, but also through PROMs (Patient Reported Outcome Measures), a type of measurement in which digital patient engagement tools can serve best as the front line, before being integrated into even more advanced experiences. This is precisely the ground on which EasyDoctor, Easy Health's Digital Patient Engagement platform, operates, digitising the collection of PROMs and PREMs along care pathways.
On this front, as highlighted in a systematic review published in May 2023 in Frontiers in Public Health, we are still at the beginning and have ample room for improvement, also thanks to Digital Patient Engagement, to the benefit of patients, health professionals, individual organisations and health systems.
VBHC (Value-Based Healthcare), HCD (Human-Centred Design), DPE (Digital Patient Engagement): behind these and many other acronyms are experiences that have shown they can improve the quality and sustainability of care, even in universal systems such as ours. Indeed, it is precisely in Europe that, thanks to the attention paid to "societal value", which adds to personal, allocative and technical value, we can aspire to a healthcare system able to make truly tangible the principles of universality, equity and solidarity so well expressed by our Law 833 of 23 December 1978 (Legge 833 del 23 dicembre 1978).